Changing my mind on water heater

[Ludington]

I was set on buying a marathon heater for roughly 1500. Then started reading some bad reviews about the connections leaking and how the connectors are only being held by a thin piece of copper.
Since my water likes to eat copper, I don't think so.
This sent me back to our esteemed pros recommending to just get the low end units for 5-600 .
I believe this is now my route... but which brand ? Ream, ao Smith?
Do yall have a preference? And warranty level ? 6 year, 10, 12 ?
Thanks

 

[sarg]

My last two have been Rheem and I've been pondering just buying another to have it on hand.

 

[Ludington]

I wish maytag still made them.

 

[Twowaxhack]

If just by the basic Rheem 6yr heater and run it until it fails. I do the same with truck tires, basic tires and run them till they’re slick.

 

[Ludington]

If just by the basic Rheem 6yr heater and run it until it fails. I do the same with truck tires, basic tires and run them till they’re slick.

Yup, that's what I'm looking at, might bump it one step to get the self cleaning , which I'm assuming is the bent fill pipe so it swirls, and the brass hose bib.

 

[breplum]

Any of the brands are equal. Our regular plumbing suppliers are so high, most of my friends are getting them at HD.

 

[Ludington]

I'm reading reviews and finding so many " leaks after being installed" makes me really wonder about the quality of these new units. (Any of them)
My 24 year old maytag is still running , I was going to replace just because of its age, now I'm thinking, run it till it dies. I hate buying crap.

 

[Twowaxhack]

I'm reading reviews and finding so many " leaks after being installed" makes me really wonder about the quality of these new units. (Any of them)
My 24 year old maytag is still running , I was going to replace just because of its age, now I'm thinking, run it till it dies. I hate buying crap.

Yeah but how many people don’t leave reviews much less good reviews. I buy a few Rheem heaters a month and I’ve never left a review. Have a had problems ? A few, yes I have but I’ve found that every brand has problems.

 

[JEG in Raleigh]

For what it’s worth, I’ve had a 50 gallon Marathon WH for 8 years with zero problems. I’m on a well with softener and backwash filter before the WH. I’ve had a second Marathon on a guest house, for 3 years with no problems also. The heating elements are unique to Marathons and I bought a set of spares to be able to replace immediately if or when an original element fails.