Why not plumb cold water into bottom of HW heater?

Plumbing Forums

Help Support Plumbing Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

homeby5

Active Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2024
Messages
25
Reaction score
3
Just curious. Why not run the cold water into bottom of HE heater, thereby eliminating need for dip tube?
I'm thinking of running mine into drain valve outlet and putting in a valved tee to drain when needed.
Be easy on me...I'm ignorant of this stuff and thinking out loud.
Thanks
 
The only problem I see if all that incoming cold water would stir up the sediment, which would cause more crap to get stuck in your aerators. Now, adding a pre-filter....hmmm?
 
Remove the drain valve, install a T such that there is a straight path from the drain and one at right angles to that. Install ball valves on both branches, attach the cold water pipe to the valve perpendicular to the straight path, and a hose adapter on the other, which will be the drain. It will be kind of bulky, but if there is space for it, that wouldn't be a problem. I think what would mostly happen with the sediment is that it would be blown up into the tank by the incoming water, especially when the hot water is running full. However, I think mostly what would happen from this is that it would cause an asymmetric distribution of the sediment in the tank, with a large depression near the water inlet, and more elsewhere. Sediment might rise all the way to the outlet, but more likely it would just swirl around near the base of the tank.

This might make it harder to get the sediment out, in that one could not blast water from the inlet and drain the tank at the same time. On the other hand, the water going in would go inward along the base towards the center, where it would either bounce off the central flue (gas) or go straight across (electric), which should stir up the bottom very well, at least along that path.

On the other hand, if there is already a water inlet with a dip tube, which there will be, I don't see enough advantages to justify a retrofit like this.
 
Back
Top