If you were a betting plumber

Always a leak · Aug 12, 2023

House was built in 1988. I have a freezeleas hose bibb I need to replace. I have tried repairing it but I cannot get it to last more than a month or two. So, would you think it is a soldered in valve or threaded? And what is your thoughts on a shark bite replacement. It is in a wall between the garage and a room in the basement. No access so I need to cut into the wall to see the connection.

Thanks

MicEd69 · Aug 12, 2023

Frost free sillcocks often have connections that can be either soldered or screwed. On new construction, they are very likely soldered.

I had a house built in 1976 and the plumber did a TERRIBLE job of soldering the connection. He used so much solder that some ran down over the valve seat. It would shut off fine, but after using it for several months, the solder lump would tear away at the washer and it would begin to leak. Sounds you may have something similar.

Joe-H · Aug 13, 2023

If I were a betting plumber I'd bet the only way to find out is to cut the wall open. Beats asking guys 1000 miles away what's in there.

Joe H

Always a leak · Aug 13, 2023

Here you go. Just opened up a portion of the wall. To the left is the hose Bibb. I would say it’s a threaded connection. Thoughts?

Twowaxhack · Aug 13, 2023

Always a leak said:
Here you go. Just opened up a portion of the wall. To the left is the hose Bibb. I would say it’s a threaded connection. Thoughts?

Correct.

havasu · Aug 13, 2023

Great information

Always a leak · Aug 13, 2023

That was too easy of a fix. Other than the old one was 1/2 longer the new Woodford unit. So a little stucco work need to be done. Thanks for everyone’s help. Another $500 saved.

havasu · Aug 13, 2023

Once drywall repairs take place, pin a note with the part number of the replacement, and write the word "threaded 12" silcock, or whatever size you used, so the wall won't need to be opened up again the next time